In the past 14 months, Rodri has found himself mostly sidelined due to an anterior cruciate ligament injury sustained against Arsenal, logging only 588 minutes with Manchester City as a result of recurring issues, the latest of which ruled him out from the midweek 4-1 win over Borussia Dortmund in the Champions League. Although Pep Guardiola has indicated that “he is not expected to be sidelined long,” the 29-year-old remains fundamental to the manager’s system. Here, we assess the alternatives …
Nico González
“The go-to alternative when Rodri is out is certainly Nico. Nico is making steps forward,” Guardiola said ahead of Sunday’s 3-1 win against Bournemouth. Measuring 6ft 2in and aged 23 at the time he was brought in for a substantial sum from Porto in the recent transfer window, González is a near mirror image of Rodri. In fact, Guardiola referred to the ex- Barcelona player as a “young Rodri” previously, yet in the match with Bournemouth there were moments when he was caught and dispossessed in midfield in a manner Rodri, at his peak, would avoid. It is scant disgrace, however, in falling short of being in the same class as the Ballon d’Or winner.
The Croatian Veteran
The ongoing unavailability of City’s sole other holding midfielder to an ankle problem could be a test for City in case González also pick up an injury throughout Rodri’s absence. Kovacic has shone regularly for City since arriving at the club from Chelsea for £25m in June 2023 and boasts a resume that shows he is a stellar talent. His past employers include Dinamo Zagreb, Inter and Real Madrid. He possesses a wealth of accolades to his name, like one La Liga title, one Premier League title and four Champions League trophies.
The Academy Graduate
Lewis has recorded 103 games for City, roughly a 25% of which have come as a deep-lying playmaker. The boy from Bury is skilled in the spatial awareness, control, tackling and stamina the duty demands in a Guardiola-led side, but the manager has highlighted Lewis’s relatively short stature as a limitation in that role. “It’s necessary to have strength, for clear reasons,” he said. “It was less [needed] in Barcelona, Bayern Munich [Guardiola’s past clubs].” Turning 21 soon, Lewis is still developing and is expected to grow.
John Stones
“His contributions to the pitch is superb ability as a centre-back and potentially as a crucial No 6.” The perspective expressed by Thomas Tuchel which aligns with Guardiola about the ‘English defender’. Among Stones’s 408 professional club appearances, 27 have come as a defensive midfielder and he shone in that role when stepping up from defense to play next to Rodri in City’s 2023 Champions League final victory over Inter. “The 360 thing was the most difficult for me,” Stones noted about playing in the position. “I haven’t got that – I believe I’ve developed, but that comes from figuring out where to get the ball and how to control it in specific scenarios.”
The Dutch Newcomer
The Dutchman was signed by City from Milan this past transfer window as a replacement for Kevin De Bruyne. As he put it himself at the summer’s Club World Cup: “The advanced midfield role is why they [City] brought me in. Now it’s up to me to fill the No 8 and do my best to demonstrate that I merit a place.” As González nursing a knock, Reijnders lined up as a holding midfielder in the previous 1-0 loss at Aston Villa and was pushed into attack when the Spaniard entered the field just after the second half, the episode offering a indication of where he ranks in Guardiola’s thinking, namely as a reserve.
The Portuguese Midfielder
Of Brazilian origin Portugal international has only played nine times as a deep-lying midfielder throughout his career with the single game in the position for City taking place against Nottingham Forest in September 2023. He played the 90 minutes and contributed an assist in a 2-0 triumph.
The Forgotten Man
The club’s squad member is still only 29. He has operated as a defensive midfielder on 164 times during his career and did well enough in the role to be selected by England. Nevertheless, it is apparent he is not trusted of Guardiola.